Search  

by Amy Beddows
16th November 2026

What allows powerful men accused of abuse to retain their cultural influence and commercial value? Ahead of the International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women in November, Amy Beddows, an author for the Journal of Gender-Based Violence, examines how Marilyn Manson’s subversive persona, cultural value and profitability may have shielded him from accountability, and asks what it will take to challenge the systems that protect powerful men accused of abuse.


Marilyn Manson, a popular figure in the goth-rock scene, is known for his controversial persona, lyrics and performances. Across nearly four decades, he has presented himself as an anti-establishment, non-heteronormative and, occasionally, gender-fluid figure, and has become very rich in the process. He is also well established in mainstream consciousness, collaborating with artists like Eminem and Kanye West.

And according to multiple sources (Rolling Stone, Metal Hammer and the Channel 4 documentary Marilyn Manson: Unmasked), he is also a prolific sexual offender, accused of sexual, physical and psychological violence against 16 women. No criminal charges have been filed, and Manson has denied all wrongdoing, describing his relationships as “entirely consensual”.

As explored in my forthcoming work on gender, violence and media, alternative artists such as Manson may use their subversive persona to ‘hide in plain sight’ to commit abuses, under the guise of art or satire. Violence is a key element of Manson’s ‘brand’: he has played a rage-filled rockstar in Antichrist Superstar, the poster-boy for school shooters in Holy Wood and a murderous lover in The High End of Low. While these performative identities provide scathing commentary on social and political norms, his real-life actions suggest less-than-progressive intentions. As an example, his self-directed video for Heart-Shaped Glasses features bloody sexual acts between him and then-partner, Evan Rachel Wood. Wood has since stated that not only were the sex scenes not simulated, but that she was drugged and raped on set and on camera.

The protection of the ‘bad boy’ image

Following the allegations against Manson, there were some immediate consequences: he was dropped by his manager and record label, lost several TV roles and faced a flurry of lawsuits. The accusations were criminally investigated but no charges filed, due to lack of evidence and statute of limitations. Subsequently, Wood created the Phoenix Act to acknowledge the realities of disclosing sexual violence and domestic abuse.

But as of writing, Manson is far from cancelled; this year, he released a new album and completed a worldwide tour. Considering the extent of his alleged abuses – which include physical harm, threats to kill, stalking and rape against 16 women – statutory and public responses raise important questions about the apparent lack of accountability for men who commit violence, especially those with power and visibility.

Similar questions arise from allegations against other self-professed ‘bad boys’, including Axl Rose, Johnny Depp, and Jared Leto.

This is not to say that there has been no accountability for abusive men within music industries. Last year, Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs was sentenced to four years in prison for abuse against two ex-girlfriends. Before that, Ian Watkins of Lostprophets was sentenced to 29 years for multiple sexual offences against children. In 2022, R Kelly was handed 30 years for exploitation, trafficking and sexual abuse of women and children.

Yet these examples suggest a pattern: it is the extremes of abuse that result in meaningful consequences; multiple victims, very young victims (including babies) and outlandish details (such as Combs’s ‘Freak Off’ parties) can make a case impossible to ignore.

The crimes of Watkins, Combs and Kelly push the boundaries of ‘acceptable’ heteronormativity, meaning we can dismiss these abusive men as anomalies, deviants or monsters. Such a neat conclusion shuts down any meaningful interrogation of the people, industries and systems that enabled their abuse of women and children.

In comparison, Manson’s (alleged) crimes are more socially acceptable, partly due to their heteronormativity (between an adult man and adult women) but also the protection afforded by his subversive persona. Violent sex is his ‘brand’, so what did the women in his sphere expect? Simultaneously, his supporters argue that Manson is targeted because of the threat he poses to the status quo.

Another aspect that may have protected Manson from meaningful consequences is his profitability. As Karen Boyle has argued, violent men have cultural value under capitalism and patriarchy, as their ‘bad boy’ image is what makes them popular. In her book, Monsters, Claire Dederer refers to certain men as ‘mega-fauna’ – too large and valuable to fall. Manson’s recognition and record sales would qualify him as such a creature. Of course, it is also possible that we simply care more about entertainment than women’s safety; believing victims is an inconvenience when it compromises an artist or product that we like.

Why accountability matters

Manson’s lack of accountability is not a singular issue. His accusers are dismissed as lying and vindictive, while he is a victim, a scapegoat, unapologetic of who he is and what he does. We hear variants of these arguments whenever a man is accused of violence, not just those in the public eye.

As we approach the International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women (25 November), it is important to confront the realities of gendered violence: one in three women, one in six men and almost half of all trans people will experience abuse.

While only a small fraction of those committing these crimes are ‘celebrity’ predators, their actions – and our responses to their actions – are crucial because they play out so publicly. This is not a demand to make an ‘example’ of Manson but a plea for accountability, regardless of the accused’s profitability or cultural value.

How we challenge the systems that protect abusers

In the face of overwhelming ambivalence to men’s violence, there are things we can do to confront the issue at different levels. Firstly, we can be vigilant to the messages we consume, especially from ‘alternative’ genres and performers. Are they peddling the same harms in different wrapping?

We can demand suspension and proper investigation, to amplify survivors’ voices and show that our appetite for accountability grows stronger with each new #MeToo moment. We can stop buying the products that make abusers – these mega-fauna – so valuable to the industries that embolden them. If men like Manson become unprofitable, the costs of protecting them will soon outweigh the benefits. Agents, tour operators, venues and promoters are all part of the machine that props up musicians and gives them a platform, legitimacy and access. Finally, we can demand accountability at a larger level, for all perpetrators, and never stop calling for it.

Change can be made. A campaign led by Male Allies Challenging Sexism (MACS) and No Stage for Abusers resulted in Manson’s Brighton show being cancelled last year. Last month, Slipknot fans threatened to boycott the band’s upcoming world tour because Manson is listed as a support act. These outcomes may feel low-level compared to the rest of his business-as-usual existence, but small waves can build to a tsunami. For those low on hope and motivation, look to Harvey Weinstein, sentenced to 15 years for sexual assault. Last week, Russell Brand was sentenced to 10 and a half years for rape and sexual assault. Mega-fauna can be brought down, if we speak loudly enough for long enough.

For many of Manson’s fans, these accusations will have been more than disappointing; his ‘anti-everything’ stance promised a different way of being. His music rallies against systems of oppression, speaking to the disenfranchised – the ‘nobodies’. Reconciling this image with the allegations of violence means confronting the possibility that his apparent rebellion was not so radical after all, and that he is part of the misogynistic status quo. But that anger and sense of betrayal can also become a source of motivation: a reason to question the cultural figures we celebrate, the industries that profit from them, and the systems that allow powerful men to evade accountability.

The challenge is not simply to unmask individual artists, but to demand meaningful change.

Amy Beddows is a trauma therapist working in Edinburgh. She has a PhD in women’s experiences of victim blame and has a special interest in the ways that media can reflect, subvert and challenge misogyny and violence against women and girls. 

 ‘Forget TV, it will never show you the experience of the victim’: representations of rape in Mindhunter by Amy Beddows from the Journal of Gender-Based Violence is available on Bristol University Press Digital.

Bristol University Press/Policy Press newsletter subscribers receive a 25% discount – sign up here.

Follow Transforming Society so we can let you know when new articles publish.

The views and opinions expressed on this blog site are solely those of the original blog post authors and other contributors. These views and opinions do not necessarily represent those of the Policy Press and/or any/all contributors to this site.

Image credit: Claudio Schwarz via Unsplash